Did two missing climbers conquer Everest before Hillary?

Did two missing climbers conquer Everest before Hillary?

On 29 May 1953, Edmund Hillary and Tenzing Norgay reached the summit of Mount Everest, becoming the first climbers confirmed to have stood on the highest point on Earth.

Their achievement made international headlines and secured their place in history. But almost three decades earlier, two British mountaineers had attempted the same feat, disappearing high on the mountain without leaving a definitive account of what happened.

Their names were George Mallory and Andrew “Sandy” Irvine.

THEY MAY HAVE REACHED THE SUMMIT 29 YEARS BEFORE HILLARY AND NORGAY.

Into the unknown

In 1924, Mount Everest remained one of the world's great unconquered challenges. British expeditions had explored its slopes in 1921 and attempted to reach the summit in 1922, but nobody had yet demonstrated that climbing to the top was possible.

George Mallory was already an experienced mountaineer, having participated in both earlier expeditions. At 37, he was determined to make another attempt. His climbing partner, Andrew Irvine, was just 22, an Oxford student and talented engineer with comparatively limited mountaineering experience.

Irvine's mechanical abilities were particularly valuable. He had worked on improving the expedition's oxygen equipment, which the climbers hoped would help them survive in the thin air at extreme altitude.

On the morning of 8 June 1924, the two men left their high camp on Everest's northern slopes and began their final push towards the summit.

They carried primitive oxygen apparatus, wore layers of wool and gabardine, and climbed in leather boots fitted with metal studs. Their equipment was a world away from the technology available to modern mountaineers.

What happened over the following hours would become one of exploration's greatest mysteries.

The last sighting

That afternoon, fellow expedition member Noel Odell was climbing below the pair when the clouds briefly parted.

High above him, he spotted two small figures moving along the mountain's northeast ridge. He watched them negotiate what appeared to be a rocky step before the clouds closed in again.

It was the last confirmed sighting of Mallory and Irvine alive.

Neither man returned to camp. Despite subsequent searches, the expedition found no conclusive evidence of how far they had climbed or where they had died.

TWO MEN DISAPPEARED NEAR THE TOP OF THE WORLD. NO ONE KNEW WHETHER THEY HAD REACHED IT.

For decades, climbers debated what Odell had actually witnessed. Had the pair been close enough to the summit to complete their ascent? Could they have overcome the formidable rock barriers along the ridge with the equipment available in 1924?

The answers remained elusive, and the mountain kept its secrets.

Clues in the ice

In 1999, an expedition searching for the missing climbers discovered Mallory's body on Everest's north face, approximately 8,100 metres above sea level.

His remains revealed evidence of a serious fall, but offered no definitive answer to the central question. Had he fallen while attempting to reach the summit, or while descending after successfully standing on top?

One intriguing detail added to the speculation. Mallory had reportedly intended to leave a photograph of his wife, Ruth, at the summit. The photograph was not found among his possessions, although its absence proved nothing.

Attention also turned to Irvine, who was believed to have carried a small Kodak camera. If recovered with its film intact, the camera might contain photographs capable of settling the debate.

Then, in September 2024, a National Geographic expedition led by photographer and filmmaker Jimmy Chin made another extraordinary discovery.

On a glacier below Everest's north face, the team found an old climbing boot containing partial human remains and a sock embroidered with the name A.C. Irvine. The discovery was believed to be the first physical evidence of Irvine's whereabouts in a century.

Yet the camera was not recovered, and the discovery did not establish whether the climbers had reached the summit.

A CENTURY OF SEARCHING HAS PRODUCED REMARKABLE CLUES, BUT STILL NO DEFINITIVE ANSWER.

Hillary and Norgay remain the first climbers confirmed to have reached Everest's summit. Their achievement is beyond dispute, regardless of what may eventually be discovered about the events of 1924.

But somewhere in the history of that mountain lies the final chapter of Mallory and Irvine's expedition.

The world knows when they disappeared.

What it may never know is how far they got.

 

_______________________

About SABRE Stories

SABRE Stories explores remarkable people, unexpected histories and fascinating ideas from across culture, art, science and the wider world. An independent editorial collection celebrating curiosity, knowledge and the art of conversation.

Unless otherwise stated, featured people, organisations and brands are not affiliated with or endorsing SABRE.